Facelift Disasters – Why They Happen and How to Avoid One

Avoid bad facelift

Magazines often feature stories about facelift disasters – disastrous facelift results.  This really is news, because in a major satisfaction survey, after one year, 97.8% described their results as “very good or beyond expectations.”  Even after 12 years, 61% still felt that way.


Editor’s Note: Dr. Brian Machida is a double-board certified plastic surgeon practicing in metro Los Angeles. He taught facial plastic surgery for years at the University of Southern California.  He can be reached at Second to Creation Plastic Surgery in Ontario, CA, part of California’s Inland Empire (see Contact below).


All the media attention on “facelift disasters” can give the wrong idea to people who are considering the many advantages of improving their looks.  Still, as we can see, they clearly do happen sometimes.  And some patients, while not experiencing “disaster,” are not completely happy with their results.  We’ll consider the answers to these questions:

  • What’s behind many of these problems?
  • How can you be sure to get the look you want and avoid the kind of results you don’t want?

The basis of many unsatisfactory facelifts

Patient 4 Before & After (Dr. Machida)Problems can occur if your surgeon doesn’t have the level of experience necessary to do a good job with the procedure you need.  Industry statistics show that the average plastic surgeon, who works on the entire body, may perform only 15 to 17 facial plastic surgeries in the average year.  In contrast, a number of my colleagues and I have each performed more than 2,500 facelifts in our careers.  Practice really does make a difference.

For example, the once popular Deep Plane facelift can provide outstanding results.  But it is a very demanding operation with a steep learning curve that requires a highly experienced surgeon.  If the surgeon does not perform it regularly enough, there is higher risk of damage to the facial nerve.  .

Patient 4 RS Before & After (Dr. Machida)The SMAS facelift targets a layer of tissue that covers, surrounds and attaches to the deeper tissues and structures of the face and neck.  It’s attached to the platysma, the superficial muscle covering the lower face and neck.  The SMAS layer underlies the entire cheek area.

Tightening the SMAS and the underlying muscles effectively lifts and rejuvenates the face.  Once the surgeon removes the excess skin, the new look can “turn back the clock” 10 years or even more.  Unlike the “windblown” look that less experienced surgeons or other techniques may produce, the effect can be very natural and attractive.  In the right hands, the SMAS facelift can provide reliable, excellent results.

Promising more and delivering less

Another source of unsatisfactory results (though not the disasters featured in the media) is selecting an inappropriate procedure.  It’s the surgeon’s responsibility to tell the patient exactly what it will take to achieve their (realistic) goals.

But in some areas competition is stiff.  It can be very tempting to allow a patient to believe that a lower-cost Mini Lift will give them the look they want when they really need a full facelift.  True candidates for less expensive Mini Lifts are primarily people whose facial aging is just past the point where non-surgical treatments can help.

Turkey NeckSo, if you have a double chin, a “turkey neck” or excessive neck fullness and your surgeon recommends a Mini Lift, ask:

  • What will you do to correct the laxity (or fullness) in my neck?
  • Will you tighten my platysma?

If your surgery will not address these areas, you would probably be happier with the results a different surgeon would provide.  It’s better for the doctor to under-promise and over-deliver than the other way around.

“Nightmare” Prevention

Effect of cigarettes on face-CUMany “plastic surgery nightmares” publicized in the national media appear to come from two main sources:

  1. Problems in the healing process
  2. Too many procedures

Both of these can often be avoided by better communication with your surgeon.  If you smoke, have diabetes, or are on blood thinners, be sure to tell your doctor.  All of these can get in the way of good healing, which could lead to a “nightmare.”  If the surgeon takes the right precautions regarding healing, you’re already halfway to good results.

Many of the “plastic surgery nightmares” I’ve seen result from too many procedures.  Again, here is where honest communication is crucial.  Patients who expect miraculous results are likely to be disappointed if their procedure results in anything less.  They may visit another surgeon.

Unfortunately they always manage to find someone willing to take their money and perform one more surgery.  But too many procedures can leave a face looking worse than not having needed work performed.  This can result in the “nightmare” photos we often see.

Realistic expectations, and consulting with an experienced, skilled, honest and straightforward plastic surgeon can make the difference between a disappointing result and getting the new look you really want.

Patient 4 Before & After (Dr. Machida)

Feature Photo (at top):  Renowned Italian fashion designer Donatella Versace at TIME 100 – photo by David Shankbone

About Dr. Brian Machida, MD, FACS

Dr. Brian K. Machida, MD, FACS is a double board certified facial plastic surgeon. He has an exceptional level of experience, having performed ( read more )

Articles by Dr. Brian Machida, MD, FACS

Cure Camera Face and Zoom Neck: The Ultimate Way to Look Better on Zoom

Do you want to look better on Zoom? Many find that webcams show them at their worst. How can you get rid of Camera Face or Zoom Neck? Inland Empire, California expert facial plastic surgeon Dr. Brian Machida tells you how [Read More]

How to Look Better and Feel Better During the Pandemic

Can you feel better – and look better during the COVID pandemic? Expert facial plastic surgeon Dr. Brian Machida tells you how – based on solid research. [Read More]

Protruding Ears and Ear Deformities – Should Teens and Adults Consider Ear Surgery – Otoplasty?

Protruding ears and ear deformities bring a lifetime of teasing and embarrassment to many. There are social and economic consequences as well. An expert facial plastic surgeon explains why Otoplasty – ear surgery – makes sense for many, and how teens and college students can afford it. [Read More]

The Facelift Price – Is it a Good Economic Investment?

Many who are considering improving their appearance wonder: Will a facelift help me, not just aesthetically and emotionally, but economically as well? You’ll want to read what years of research reveals. [Read More]

Turkey Neck – What’s the Most Reliable Treatment?

The dreaded Turkey Neck – loose neck skin or visible V-shaped neck [Read More]

Excess Neck Fat – What’s the Best Solution?

Too much neck fat isn’t good for your health or your looks. An expert facial plastic surgeon shows the best ways to streamline your neck at any age. [Read More]

Is Now the Best Time for a Facelift?

Is it safe to get a facelift, neck lift or blepharoplasty during the COVID-19 pandemic? It may be the best time for a procedure, according to highly experienced facial plastic surgeon Dr. Brian Machida, who taught for years at USC’s medical school. Find out why in his research-based article. [Read More]

Acne Scars – How Can You Successfully Treat Them?

Bothered by acne scars? Which acne scar treatments are effective? Inland Empire, California expert Dr. Brian Machida discusses some excellent treatments for mild, moderate and severe acne scars. One even works for darker skin. [Read More]

Fillers – Getting the Most from Fat Transfer or Bellafill, Radiesse and Voluma Injections

Fillers to restore facial volume are very popular. Is Juvederm Voluma, Radiesse, or Bellafill best for you? Or is fat transfer using the BeautiFill fat grafting system a better option? Inland Empire expert Dr. Brian Machida gives you the facts. [Read More]

Blepharoplasty (Eyelid Surgery) and a Facelift – Should You Have Them at the Same Time?

Should you consider having a facelift and blepharoplasty together? Each can do a great job of helping you look younger. Is it a good idea to have a facelift and eyelid surgery at the same time? An expert facial plastic surgeon from Inland Empire, metro Los Angeles California shares his insights. [Read More]